Are your kids’ dreams worth $4,000?

The headlines surrounding Lori Loughlin’s high profile arrest for her role in a nationwide college admissions scheme are impossible to ignore. Details are salacious and, for “normal Joe’s” like me, the estimates of the family’s bribes to ensure admission for their two daughters to the University of Southern California are jaw-dropping.

Photo: BBC

By most reports, Loughlin and her husband paid more than half a million dollars for their girls to be USC Trojans – that’s just crazy, right?

But, wait…when you do some quick math, add some context and look in the mirror, I wonder if the chorus of flabbergasted parents, like me, would turn down our outrage-filled volume toward the now-evicted Full House star.

Aunt Becky’s math problem is simple:

The Loughlin/Mossimo household has an estimated net worth of $88 million. The payments for the alleged scheme, reportedly $500,000, would have eaten up a grand total of 0.6% of that value.

Aunt Becky math applied to the “normal Joe”:

According to Federal Reserve’s Survey of Consumer Finances, the average American family’s net worth is $692,100. If “Joe” wanted to participate in a similar fraud using the same personal equity of the Loughlin/Mossimo household, he’d be shelling out $3,932.

While $4,000 is nothing to scoff at, the figure does not seem as incomprehensible – comparable to that of a rundown used car or, likely, “Joe’s” wife’s engagement ring.

Hmm.

But, you might say, the Lori Loughlin loathing has nothing to do with the money. After all, it’s no surprise that these celebrities throw around $1,000 like I do a $5 bill. The real issue, some say, is the message that you can butt into line (or skip the line altogether) if you have the means to do so.

In that context, I’m reminded of an article I wrote a few years ago after watching my kids’ dejected faces as others paid a premium to cut lines during a family outing to Universal Studios.

Last weekend I was reminded of a phenomenon that had bothered me a few months ago – the concept of paying for the right to cut in line.  The Universal Studios “Fast-Pass” brought me right back to the scorn I felt for the “Santa’s Helper” line at my local mall during the Christmas season.

My wife thinks I’m crazy for getting worked up about something like this.  She justifiably files my complaints for this inequity between my jealousies for those with more money and families having fewer children.  I’m guilty – in part.

I’ll acknowledge that I might be jealous of those paying to budge in line.  I would consider doing the same if calculating the price of doing so did not require a calculator.

Re-reading the excerpt, I can’t ignore my own hypocrisy related to the Loughlin allegations.

I try to reassure myself – I’d pay-to-budge at a theme park, but never with something as monumental as college admission, right?

They will think cipla cialis india light headed and also light-headed. Autism is a developmental disorder associated with neuronal http://amerikabulteni.com/2012/02/01/michelle-obama-barack-bana-her-zaman-sarki-soyluyor/ generico levitra on line damage and has been linked with various accidental traumas offered to the brain, due to vaccine injury, heavy metals, toxic food administration and technical faults during deliveries. If you are not comfortable walking to your local chemist to buy the medicine you may want to let viagra prescription Kama Rani help. If you experience poor erections on a regular basis. cheap viagra in india

If my oldest, Yosef, worked his tail off and was falling just short of his lifelong ambition to attend Harvard and, for $4k I could guaranty his admission, would I pay up?

95% of me wants to quickly laugh off the idea – no way!

I can’t, though, ignore the 5% that would make me forever wonder if bending the rules in the name of my child’s dream would be, just this once, morally permissible.

Feel free to question my moral compass but know that my honesty and self-reflection are sincere.

In my “normal Joe” life, when I can, I do everything in my power to pave the path for my kids’ dreams – in school, in civic opportunities and on their various fields of play.

Hell, I write sizable checks (at least for me) so that Lynden, my 11 year-old, can play club soccer. And, while my checks don’t blatantly influence whether he is selected for the team, the ability to do so as blatantly pre-determines the group of players he needs to beat out to participate.

Maybe the parenting outrage for Lori Loughlin is missing one thing: the playing fields are not level.

Not in academics.

Not in sports.

Not in S.T.E.M competitions.

And, unfortunately, not in life.

Leveling the field takes years, even decades and generations, of hard work and dogged determination. It can be done, just not overnight and certainty not by pointing at celebrities as perpetrators of social injustice.

This does not mean, though, cheating is okay.

It does, however, mean that parents are naive to ignore that most decks are stacked and, additionally, to recognize our own hypocrisy when we are the ones dealing the cards.

Facebooktwitterredditpinterestlinkedinmail

4 Replies to “Are your kids’ dreams worth $4,000?”

  1. Agree with your comment on stacking the deck, but keep in mind that some of this money went to paying other people to take their entrance exams. This is clearly “cheating”. Other people who scored better than what these kids would have scored could have gotten in these schools. Second point is that there were only a few who got caught. This is a lot larger then you think. To say that influential people like Obama or Bush don’t get preferential treatment when their children apply would not be honest. Finally your analogy of your child only having to compete against those who could pay the $$ for soccer is not a true analogy. The standard for entry is application fee $$. The true analogy would be if you sons did not pay anything, but got in for free because you knew a coach or something and took the spot of someone who could have paid. The same goes for Disney. Fast Past fee is the standard. If someone didn’t pay, but still got the pass, would not be fair. Likewise the Standard for entry is Admission Tests. If you score high enough, it qualifies you consideration. Having someone fake the test scores means someone else could have gotten in.
    It is also comical for the Hollywood people to be roasting these people, as from a moral perspective, they are just as bankrupt. Just my two cents worth.

  2. You totally made me think in a different way about this. It’s true…money does pave the way. I am appalled at what these parents have done. It’s totally cheating. However, we can’t overlook that the field isn’t even and probably never will be. Case and point…my nephew had parents that draw very healthy incomes. They were able to hire a college coach to help him decide on universities, give him advice on college essays, provide him with information that helps give him insight into some of the top schools. The coach even helps with scholarships. Not every child gets this experience. I’m extremely grateful for this as it’s helped him receive entrance into extremely competitive schools, but it also makes my heart ache for those who can’t afford this assistance. That’s why I constantly push for more career and college guidance for ALL students.

    Thanks for the different perspective, Toby!

    • Thx for reading! The good news, I think, is that these situations now are found out and exposed via the quick and transparent news cycle. That should make these injustices more difficult to perpetrate. But, I still think there is a long, long way to go as parents continue to find new, expansive ways to limit opportunities for those around us that might not be able to pay.

  3. Unfortunately, life isn’t fair. Some of us are born short and some tall. Some are born into wealth, while others struggle to make ends meet. Whether it is a job, healthcare, college admissions, or sports teams, there will always be limits set due to cost, resources, or headcount. And you are right in that the system is set up to “look” fair, when in reality there are a lot of “politics” that go on behind the scenes. The old saying, “its not what you know, but who you know” holds true in a lot of situations (getting a job being one of those). The only thing I can do is to make sure that the things I do are open and honest. Like my basketball sports league I help run in the summer. We make it simple. First come, first served. We only have a facility that will allow us to take 40 kids per age bracket, so the first kids who sign up are in and the others are put on a wait list. I wish we could admit everyone, but thus is life. Have a great day. 🙂

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*